Pearl Newbie - Questions re: choosing the right color pearls

WannaBeAPearl

Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2025
Messages
2
Hi, all - I've been lurking here reading for a while (so much incredible info/photos), watching YouTube vids w/ Jeremy from Pearl Paradise, etc.... and think I might finally be ready to move on from dreaming about pearls to actually owning some. Based on my current style preferences, I think I'd get the most use from a pendant style necklace and earrings in simple yellow gold settings. For the pendant, my favorite is a simple gold bail, like the below Mikimoto pendant, with a 7-8mm round or drop shaped pearl. And for earrings, I would love a simple pair of 6-7mm studs or a pair in a front/back style, like Dior tribales, such as the below ones I found on a website for a company called Gingerberi.
1750531369306.png
1750531825202.png



I'm still a bit confused as to color, however, and appreciate in advance any advice you can share with me! So, although I know I should prioritize luster, color is really forefront in my mind, as I have a very strong preference for warmer-toned, ivory/cream colored pearls (and somewhat of an aversion to pinkish ones). I was initially drawn to akoya pearls, but from what I understand, akoya pearls are either "pinked" or natural white, which tend to be a cooler white color - neither of which is my ideal. I briefly looked at white South Sea pearls, but they also seem to largely have cool overtones.... and they're all kind of huge lol. Thus, it seems like freshwater pearls might be my best option?

And my second question - once I've narrowed down the type of pearl most likely to be the color ivory I'm after, what is the liklihood of nonetheless getting pearls that are cooler white and/or with pinkish/blue overtones? Although I do live in a large city (Dallas) and therefore have access to some larger jewelry retailers, shopping for pearls in person hasn't proved very helpful. So far, I made an appointment with my sales associate at Tiffany's, but she had very little stock to show me and was upfront that she doesn't really have much knowledge about pearls, and I also tried Zales and Jared, but they had even fewer pieces. I've also spent hours and hours combing through the websites of all the usual suspects - Mikimoto, Tiffany, Pearl Paradise, the Pearl Source, plus loads I'm not really familar with - and it seems like the vast majority of items are not listed invidually - as in, the earrings/pendants in the listing photos are generic and are not of the actual pieces that I would receive. And I'm certain that my small earrings/pendant are not even close to the price point that would warrant a special order at Mikimoto etc so that I could choose the pearls or at least see them first -and I feel super awkward returning fine jewelry pieces (especially if it might take several tries to get the right thing). However, to be honest, I would be kind of gutted if I ended up feeling stuck with ones that I don't really love... so much so I keep thinking perhaps I should just scrap the whole thing. But, I really, really, really LOL want to add some pearls to my jewelry collection, so again, any and all advice/thoughts are welcome! (Also, so sorry this post is so long, and thank you so much for reading all the way to the end)! :)
 
Hi WannaBeAPearl, and welcome to the forum! My first suggestion would be to not make a purchase from a stock website photo. If you are interested in a specific color, overtone, size, etc, in any type of pearl, I would contact the vendor and ask what is available from their current inventory. Just about all the vendors that have been mentioned on this site will have inventory they can describe and send pics to you. I like creamy Akoya, too, and there are options out there that are not pinky or natural white. I have some beautiful golden Akoya from Takahashi pearl, and some beautiful vintage Akoya in various shades of ivory to golden from Kojima Pearl/Pacific Pearls.US. Takahashi specializes in Akoya and Kojima/PacificPearls currently have a large inventory of vintage Akoya. Pearl Paradise also carries Akoya and you can make a virtual appointment to have them show you what they have available for the pieces you have in mind. I’m attaching a pic of three of my necklaces. In the back is a strand of golden Akoya from Takahashi, middle is a vintage Akoya strand from PacificPearls.US, and in the front is a necklace of random vintage Akoya I chose from loose boxes of PacificPearls. They were loose and undrilled and you can see a variety of shades that are not white or pinked.
IMG_3976.jpeg


A variety of ivory to creamy shades of Akoya
IMG_3977.jpeg
 
Hi WannaBeAPearl, and welcome to the forum! My first suggestion would be to not make a purchase from a stock website photo. If you are interested in a specific color, overtone, size, etc, in any type of pearl, I would contact the vendor and ask what is available from their current inventory. Just about all the vendors that have been mentioned on this site will have inventory they can describe and send pics to you. I like creamy Akoya, too, and there are options out there that are not pinky or natural white. I have some beautiful golden Akoya from Takahashi pearl, and some beautiful vintage Akoya in various shades of ivory to golden from Kojima Pearl/Pacific Pearls.US. Takahashi specializes in Akoya and Kojima/PacificPearls currently have a large inventory of vintage Akoya. Pearl Paradise also carries Akoya and you can make a virtual appointment to have them show you what they have available for the pieces you have in mind. I’m attaching a pic of three of my necklaces. In the back is a strand of golden Akoya from Takahashi, middle is a vintage Akoya strand from PacificPearls.US, and in the front is a necklace of random vintage Akoya I chose from loose boxes of PacificPearls. They were loose and undrilled and you can see a variety of shades that are not white or pinked.


A variety of ivory to creamy shades of Akoya
Thank you so much for the info, and I really appreciate the pics w/ comparisons! Those are all beautiful (and I especially like the lighter ones and the more yellow ones in the last strand). And that is great to know that even though my spend amount will be pretty insignificant relatively speaking, that I can still see the pearls ahead of time. That gives me much more peace of mind, and I'm going to reach out to PP on Monday to schedule an appointment. :) :) :)
 
You can also ask about freshwater pearls. They come in a wide range of colors and sizes and would also be more budget friendly, unless you are set on Akoya.
 
Back
Top